Summary
Introduction
Contemporary society faces a paradoxical crisis: the more freedom we gain, the more exhausted we become. This phenomenon challenges traditional understanding of power, control, and human flourishing in the modern world. The transition from external coercion to self-imposed achievement pressure has created new forms of violence that operate not through prohibition, but through the relentless demand for optimization and performance.
The analysis reveals how neurological disorders like depression, ADHD, and burnout syndrome have replaced infectious diseases as the defining pathologies of our time. These conditions emerge not from external threats but from an excess of positivity—too much stimulation, too many possibilities, and relentless self-exploitation disguised as freedom. By examining this shift through philosophical, psychological, and sociological lenses, we can understand how the promise of liberation has transformed into a more subtle but equally devastating form of control.
Beyond Immunological Defense: The Rise of Neuronal Violence
The twenty-first century marks a fundamental shift in the nature of social pathology. Where previous eras were defined by bacterial infections combated through antibiotics or viral outbreaks managed through immunological responses, contemporary maladies operate through entirely different mechanisms. Depression, attention deficit disorders, and burnout syndrome represent not infections but infarctions—breakdowns caused by excess rather than invasion.
Traditional immunological thinking relied on clear distinctions between self and other, inside and outside, friend and enemy. The Cold War epitomized this paradigm, organizing society around defensive reactions against foreign threats. However, this framework proves inadequate for understanding current conditions where otherness itself has largely disappeared, replaced by the proliferation of sameness.
The violence of positivity operates through saturation rather than deprivation, inclusion rather than exclusion. Unlike viral violence that infiltrates systems from outside, neuronal violence emerges from within—it is systemic and immanent. This creates a terror of immanence that cannot be addressed through traditional defensive measures because there is no external enemy to combat.
Contemporary society's promiscuous mixing of boundaries and constant hybridization stands diametrically opposed to immunological organization. The general absence of meaningful otherness enables this universal exchange while simultaneously creating new forms of suffering that emerge from overproduction, overachievement, and overcommunication rather than scarcity or invasion.
From Disciplinary Prohibition to Achievement Compulsion
The transformation from disciplinary society to achievement society represents more than a simple evolution—it constitutes a fundamental restructuring of power relations. Disciplinary society operated through the negativity of prohibition, organizing life around "May Not" and "Should." Its institutions—hospitals, prisons, factories, schools—created clear boundaries between normal and abnormal, acceptable and forbidden.
Achievement society discards this negative framework in favor of unlimited possibility. The governing modal verb becomes "Can," epitomized in slogans like "Yes, we can." Projects, initiatives, and motivation replace prohibitions, commandments, and laws. Where disciplinary society produced madmen and criminals through its negative constraints, achievement society generates depressives and losers through positive overload.
This shift maintains continuity in one crucial aspect: the drive to maximize productivity. The social unconscious switches from "Should" to "Can" not to reduce performance demands but to enhance them. Positive potency proves more efficient than negative constraint because it operates through the illusion of freedom rather than obvious coercion.
The achievement-subject appears liberated from external domination, functioning as entrepreneur of the self rather than obedient subordinate. However, this apparent freedom conceals a more insidious form of control. The subject becomes simultaneously lord and slave, exploiter and exploited, perpetrator and victim. This self-referential structure produces a paradoxical freedom that transforms rapidly into compulsive self-optimization and ultimately auto-aggression.
The Pathology of Positivity: Depression and Self-Exploitation
Depression emerges as the signature malady of achievement society, but not for the reasons commonly assumed. Rather than resulting from repressed conflicts or external oppression, contemporary depression stems from the exhausted inability to continue performing. The depressive complaint "Nothing is possible" can only arise in a context that insists "Nothing is impossible."
The achievement-subject differs fundamentally from both the Freudian disciplinary subject and the Kantian moral subject. Where these earlier forms operated through internal division—ego versus superego, duty versus inclination—the contemporary subject attempts total self-integration around performance optimization. This creates a form of violence more devastating than external oppression because it operates through apparent self-determination.
The crisis of gratification plays a crucial role in this pathology. Traditional structures provided clear mechanisms for recognition and reward through external authorities—God, society, established institutions. The achievement-subject, however, exists in radical isolation, unable to provide genuine acknowledgment for its own accomplishments. This creates an endless spiral of performance escalation in search of satisfaction that never arrives.
Burnout syndrome represents the ultimate endpoint of this process. The exhausted subject has overheated from too much of the same, grinding itself down in a rat race against its own previous achievements. Unlike traditional melancholia, which maintained relation to lost objects, contemporary depression is entirely objectless and therefore undirected, lacking the gravity that would provide existential weight.
Contemplative Resistance: Reclaiming the Vita Contemplativa
The rehabilitation of contemplative attention offers potential resistance to hyperactive exhaustion. Learning to see, in Nietzsche's formulation, requires developing patience and the capacity for deep, sustained focus. This means cultivating "inhibiting, excluding instincts" that can resist immediate reactive responses to stimuli.
Contemporary society suffers from profound poverty of interruption and interval. Acceleration eliminates all "between-times," creating mechanical activity that rolls forward like a stone in obedience to physical laws. This differs qualitatively from higher forms of activity that incorporate pause, reflection, and genuine choice.
The capacity for contemplation should not be confused with passive reception or romantic withdrawal from engagement. True contemplative attention actively resists crowding stimuli while maintaining sovereign control over perception and response. It operates through a form of active negation—the power not to do—which differs fundamentally from mere impotence or inability.
Deep boredom, far from representing emptiness or waste, provides essential conditions for creative development. Benjamin's "dream bird that hatches the egg of experience" requires protected spaces of tranquility increasingly absent from hyperconnected environments. The loss of such contemplative capacity directly contributes to the hysteria and nervousness characteristic of contemporary social life.
The Society of Tiredness: Toward Collective Exhaustion
Two fundamentally different forms of tiredness characterize contemporary experience. Divisive tiredness isolates and separates, destroying common language and shared experience. This "I-tiredness" reflects the exhausted ego's complete self-absorption, creating violence through its inability to perceive or relate to others.
Fundamental tiredness, by contrast, opens possibilities for genuine community and shared existence. This "we-tiredness" loosens the strictures of isolated selfhood, creating space for what Handke calls "more of less of me." Rather than representing incapacity, such tiredness enables a special form of vision that perceives slow, long forms invisible to hyperactive attention.
The inspiration of tiredness operates through the negative potency of not-doing rather than the positive exhaustion of overactivity. Like the Sabbath as a day of stopping, this represents sacred time freed from instrumental calculation and endless productivity. It creates intervals where useless activities become possible and valuable.
This tired community requires no kinship or functional connection, operating instead through what might be called friendly indifference. Things and beings show themselves connected through simple conjunction rather than subordination or exploitation. Such tiredness proves disarming, replacing the resolution of aggressive achievement with genuine calm and openness to encounter.
Summary
The fundamental insight emerging from this analysis concerns how apparent liberation can mask more subtle but equally devastating forms of control. The shift from external prohibition to internal compulsion represents not progress toward freedom but the evolution of power into more efficient forms that operate through subjects' sense of self-determination rather than obvious coercion.
Contemporary neurological pathologies reveal the violence inherent in systems organized around endless positivity and optimization. The exhausted, burnt-out subject represents not personal failure but systemic consequence of social arrangements that demand constant self-improvement while eliminating the contemplative capacities necessary for sustainable human flourishing. Recovery requires not simply individual therapy but fundamental reconsideration of how societies might organize themselves around genuine rest, reflection, and forms of community that transcend competitive achievement.
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.


