Summary
Introduction
In our hyperconnected yet profoundly lonely age, millions of people wake up each morning feeling spiritually adrift. We scroll through endless feeds searching for meaning, rush through our days checking boxes on productivity apps, and collapse into bed wondering why life feels so empty despite being busier than ever. Traditional religious institutions no longer speak to our lived experience, yet our souls still hunger for something transcendent, something that connects us to ourselves, each other, and the greater mystery of existence.
This disconnection isn't just emotionally painful—it's literally killing us. Studies show that social isolation is more harmful to our health than smoking fifteen cigarettes a day, while rates of anxiety, depression, and suicide continue to climb. Yet beneath this crisis of meaning lies an extraordinary opportunity. All around us, people are discovering that the activities they already do—reading, eating, exercising, walking—can become powerful spiritual practices when infused with intention, attention, and repetition. From CrossFit boxes functioning as congregations to dinner parties becoming healing circles, we're witnessing a profound transformation in how humans create meaning and community in the modern world.
Connecting with Self: Sacred Reading and Sabbath Time
Growing up as a lonely, closeted teenager at an English boarding school, Casper ter Kuile found solace in an unlikely place: the romantic comedy "You've Got Mail." What began as escapist entertainment gradually transformed into something deeper as he created specific rituals around watching the film—always alone, always with Pralines and Cream ice cream, always when feeling lost and in need of comfort. Certain lines became mantras inscribed on his heart, characters became totems of who he wanted to be, and what was once just another movie became sacred text.
Years later, ter Kuile would co-create the award-winning podcast "Harry Potter and the Sacred Text," applying ancient practices like lectio divina to J.K. Rowling's beloved series. Through the four-stage ladder of sacred reading—examining what's literally happening, exploring metaphorical connections, reflecting on personal experiences, and discerning calls to action—ordinary stories become mirrors for self-discovery. Listeners write in describing how this practice helped them process trauma, navigate major life decisions, and develop greater empathy for themselves and others.
The practice of sabbath offers another pathway to authentic self-connection. Inspired by Abraham Joshua Heschel's understanding of sabbath as "a palace in time," ter Kuile began observing a twenty-four-hour tech sabbath every Friday night through Saturday night. As darkness falls, he lights a candle and sings, instantly feeling his shoulders relax as he enters what Heschel called the climax of living—time devoted not to productivity but to simply being. Without the constant ping of notifications, space opens for creativity, reflection, and the remembered joy of existing without agenda.
These practices of sacred reading and sabbath time reveal a fundamental truth about spiritual life: we don't need to acquire anything new to connect with our deepest selves. The materials for transformation already exist in our daily habits, waiting to be approached with the reverence and attention they deserve.
Connecting with Others: Sacred Meals and Embodied Community
When Lennon Flowers lost her mother to cancer during college, she struggled with a peculiar form of social isolation. She longed to talk about her mom's life and lasting influence, but bringing up her loss in casual conversation felt like wielding a conversation-killer. Simple questions about holiday plans or Mother's Day would create awkward silences, leaving her feeling more alone than ever. So in 2010, Flowers and her friend Carla Fernandez hosted a dinner in their backyard, bringing together a small group of twentysomethings united by the experience of significant loss.
That first gathering birthed what would become the Dinner Party, now a global community with over 270 tables meeting regularly in 95 cities worldwide. Each month, members bring homemade dishes—often foods that remind them of their lost loved ones—and gather around tables where grief transforms into connection. Because everyone understands loss intimately, no topic feels off-limits. They can speak honestly about anger and relief alongside sadness, about the complicated realities of loving imperfect people who are no longer here.
The genius of the Dinner Party lies in its recognition that eating together remains humanity's most fundamental community-building practice. Since our ancestors first shared the spoils of hunting and gathering, breaking bread has signified kinship, trust, and belonging. Even the act of eating provides natural rhythms for conversation—the pauses to chew, the passing of dishes, the shared focus on nourishment creates space for both intimacy and comfortable silence.
Beyond the dinner table, embodied communities are emerging in fitness spaces across the country. At SoulCycle, riders move in unison to pounding music in darkened, candlelit rooms, their individual efforts merging into collective energy. Instructors like former track athlete Angela Davis weave spiritual language throughout the workout: "There's a blessing waiting for you on this bike! Angels are clapping for you!" During the penultimate hill climb, when resistance increases and music slows, tears often flow as barriers dissolve and riders access their most vulnerable, authentic selves.
These communities reveal that connection isn't built through conversation alone, but through shared rhythms of breath, movement, and presence. Whether gathered around food or united in physical challenge, we remember our fundamental interdependence and discover that healing happens not in isolation, but in the courage to be witnessed by others.
Connecting with Nature: Pilgrimage and Seasonal Celebration
Walking through the Oxfordshire countryside with modern-day troubadour Will Parsons, ter Kuile discovered that pilgrimage need not involve epic journeys to distant shrines. Their daylong walk from Oxford to a twelfth-century church outside Binsey village followed the simple three-part architecture of all sacred journeys: setting intention, undertaking the transformative journey itself, and returning home changed. Along the way, Parsons encouraged practices that deepened their connection to the landscape—finding walking sticks from fallen branches, brewing tea from foraged dandelion leaves, and learning the legend of Saint Frideswide, whose story brought the very fields and hedgerows to life with meaning.
At their destination, they didn't rush immediately into the church but stopped first at an enormous yew tree, over three hundred years old, towering beside the building. Parsons led them in circumambulation, walking three times around the ancient tree—a practice that transformed their casual approach into sacred ritual. By the third circuit, ter Kuile felt drawn to embrace the tree's ragged bark, experiencing a surprising intimacy with this magnificent living presence.
Modern urban life increasingly disconnects us from natural rhythms, yet the hunger for seasonal connection persists. Growing up in rural England, ter Kuile experienced the joy of marking time through festivals aligned with nature's cycles. On May Day, they rose before dawn to watch Morris dancers emerge from trees as the sun crested the horizon. Midsummer Eve brought enormous bonfires where graduating students would leap over flames as they dwindled into the night. These celebrations created what theologian Alexander Schmemann called "liturgical time"—not the linear progression of calendar dates but the eternal spiral of returning seasons.
Contemporary communities are rediscovering this wisdom in unexpected ways. At the Artisan's Asylum maker space, artists celebrate "Makersgiving" each autumn, combining potluck dishes with creations from their workshops—jewelry, sculptures, robot parts—transforming Thanksgiving into a feast of both food and creativity. The At the Well organization revives Hebrew lunar cycles through monthly Rosh Chodesh gatherings, creating space for women to connect with body, soul, and community as the moon renews itself.
These practices of pilgrimage and seasonal celebration remind us that we are not separate from nature but nature itself. When we remember our place within the great turning of seasons and cycles, we discover that the earth is not merely our environment but our larger body, deserving reverence, protection, and love.
Connecting with Transcendence: Prayer as Primary Speech
Standing bare-chested in his teenage bedroom, ter Kuile rubbed lavender essential oil into his palms while ocean sounds played from his stereo. Moving his hands just above his body before placing them over his heart, he suddenly found himself crying—not from sadness but from an overwhelming sense of being held by something infinitely larger than himself. The "I" that felt pain had melted into a presence that could hold all suffering without flinching, leaving him with an inexplicable certainty that everything would be okay.
This embarrassing teenage experiment introduced him to what scholars Ann and Barry Ulanov call "primary speech"—the fundamental human practice of prayer. Far from being a cosmic vending machine for wishes, prayer represents our deepest dialogue with mystery, the process of becoming conscious of who we really are beneath our social masks and defensive strategies. Russian Orthodox writer Anthony Bloom describes authentic prayer as the moment when things "suddenly disclose themselves with a depth we have never before perceived," establishing us in relationships where everything becomes love.
The four movements of classical prayer—adoration, contrition, thanksgiving, and supplication—provide structure for this inner journey. Adoration lifts our attention beyond individual concerns toward the vast beauty holding all existence, whether through music, massage, or simple attention to the color green. Contrition creates space for honest self-examination, ideally practiced within small groups where we can speak our failures and shortcomings without shame, knowing we'll be fiercely loved regardless.
Thanksgiving cultivates gratitude not just for material blessings but for the astonishing gift of existence itself, while supplication holds others in compassionate awareness through practices like loving-kindness meditation. Perhaps most powerfully, prayer becomes the art of blessing—drawing circles of light around people and situations, affirming both our inherent wholeness and fundamental interconnectedness.
The key insight emerges through ter Kuile's own adaptation of the Lord's Prayer, drawing cards from a forest-themed tarot deck each morning to reimagine the divine: "Our Wolf, who art in Heaven" or "Our Balance, who art in Heaven." Prayer invites creative engagement with mystery, whether through journaling, movement, art, or song, always returning us to what Walter Burghardt called "a long loving look at the real."
Already Connected: Living a Rule of Life
During his time with the CrossFit community, ter Kuile observed founder Greg Glassman's profound insight: "Community is built through shared suffering and laughter." But beneath this practical wisdom lay something deeper—the recognition that connection isn't something we create but something we remember. As Celtic philosopher John O'Donohue explained, we are already "dangerously involved with each other in an incredibly intimate but unseen way." The project isn't building community from scratch but awakening to the connections that already surround us.
This paradox runs throughout spiritual life: we are simultaneously utterly alone and completely interconnected, profoundly isolated and eternally beloved. Paul Tillich captured this mystery in his observation that "existence is separation," yet separation itself reveals the deeper unity from which we've never actually departed. The practices explored throughout this journey—sacred reading, sabbath rest, communal meals, embodied movement, pilgrimage, seasonal celebration, and prayer—serve not as techniques for manufacturing connection but as ways of remembering what has always been true.
A Rule of Life offers a framework for holding these practices together, drawing on monastic wisdom to create sustainable rhythms rather than spiritual to-do lists. Like the ancient practitioners who would read one rule each morning, we can craft our own guiding principles around the four levels of connection, acknowledging both our deep longing for meaning and our tendency to forget what matters most when life gets demanding.
The transformation happens through commitment over time, returning again and again to the same practices even when—especially when—they feel empty or pointless. Just as ter Kuile and his podcast co-host Vanessa Zoltan discovered new depths in Harry Potter after hundreds of episodes, spiritual maturity emerges through faithful repetition rather than constant novelty. What we practice, we become.
Summary
The crisis of meaning plaguing our hyperconnected yet profoundly lonely age has created an unprecedented opportunity for spiritual innovation. As traditional religious institutions lose relevance for increasing numbers of people, we're discovering that the activities we already do—reading, eating, walking, resting—can become powerful practices of connection when approached with intention, attention, and repetition. From sacred reading groups wrestling with Harry Potter to dinner parties transforming grief into community, from tech sabbaths creating space for authentic selfhood to fitness communities building embodied belonging, a quiet revolution is underway in how humans create meaning.
The deepest insight emerging from this exploration is that we need not manufacture connection from nothing—we need only remember what has always been true. Beneath our surface isolation lies an unbreakable web of interdependence connecting us to ourselves, each other, the natural world, and the great mystery of existence itself. The practices explored here serve as gentle reminders of this eternal truth, returning us again and again to the recognition that we are already home, already held, already enough. In a world that profits from our forgetting, remembering becomes the most radical act of all.
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.


