How to Think More About Sex



Summary
Introduction
Sexual desire presents one of humanity's most enduring paradoxes. Despite centuries of social progress and psychological understanding, we remain profoundly confused about this fundamental aspect of human nature. Rather than accepting the contemporary narrative that sexual liberation has solved our ancient problems, this philosophical investigation argues that sex is inherently disruptive to civilized life—not due to religious repression or social taboos, but because of its essential nature as a force that cannot be easily integrated with our other vital pursuits.
The examination proceeds through careful analysis of both the profound pleasures and intractable problems that sexual desire creates. By challenging prevailing assumptions about sexual normalcy and exploring the psychological mechanisms underlying attraction, rejection, and long-term relationships, we can develop a more realistic understanding of sex's role in human life. This approach reveals why sexual frustration and complexity are not aberrations to be cured, but inevitable features of the human condition that require thoughtful accommodation rather than utopian solutions.
The Evolutionary Fallacy: Why Sexual Attraction Transcends Biological Imperatives
Contemporary culture relies heavily on evolutionary biology to explain sexual attraction, reducing desire to unconscious calculations about reproductive fitness and genetic health. This biological determinism suggests that facial symmetry, physical proportion, and other markers of genetic viability drive our sexual choices. While this framework offers scientific credibility, it fundamentally misrepresents the conscious experience of attraction and desire.
Sexual attraction operates on far more complex psychological terrain than mere health assessment. When we declare someone "sexy," we respond not simply to their genetic fitness but to their entire character as expressed through physical appearance. The face becomes a repository of virtue, suggesting qualities like dignity, tolerance, intelligence, or courage that promise emotional compatibility. Similarly, clothing and personal style communicate philosophical positions about how life should be lived, making fashion choices into statements about values rather than mere biological displays.
The phenomenon of fetishism further reveals the inadequacy of purely evolutionary explanations. Individual sexual preferences trace back to specific childhood experiences and psychological needs rather than universal biological imperatives. A preference for particular shoes or watches represents unconscious attempts to recapture lost security or escape traumatic associations. These highly personal attractions cannot be reduced to survival strategies but instead reveal sex as a pathway toward psychological completion.
Sexual excitement emerges most powerfully at the intersection of the formal and intimate, where conventional social barriers are transgressed. The thrill of sexuality often depends on overcoming professional distance or social propriety—imagining encounters in libraries, offices, or other "forbidden" spaces. This dynamic has nothing to do with reproduction and everything to do with the human need to escape alienation through intimate connection.
The experience of orgasm represents not merely physical release but the temporary resolution of existential loneliness. Peak sexual pleasure occurs when we recognize in another person someone who shares our deepest values and understanding of existence. This recognition transcends biological function to become a profound form of spiritual communion between two conscious beings seeking meaning and connection.
The Loneliness Thesis: How Eroticism Functions as Antidote to Isolation
Modern adult life imposes a devastating form of isolation that begins in childhood's end. Where early life often provides unconditional physical and emotional intimacy, maturity demands that we hide our bodies, monitor our expressions, and earn approval through performance rather than simply existing. We develop shameful secret selves that seem impossible to share with others, particularly around sexuality, which appears to contradict our public personas as rational, moral beings.
The first kiss between potential lovers represents a miraculous overcoming of this fundamental isolation. Two people who have spent years carefully maintaining social distance suddenly permit unprecedented intimacy, allowing access to private spaces both physical and psychological. This moment thrills not primarily because of physical sensation but because it signals mutual acceptance despite our fears of being found disgusting or strange.
Undressing with another person reverses the shame imposed by civilization, which teaches us to hide our bodies and desires from adolescence onward. Sexual nakedness becomes a return to childhood's innocence, where our physical selves could inspire delight rather than revulsion. The joy of being seen naked by someone who responds with pleasure rather than disgust temporarily heals the wound inflicted by society's demand that we cover and control our animal nature.
Erotic excitement often depends on authenticity—the involuntary physical responses that cannot be faked or manipulated. Wetness and erection serve as unambiguous signs of genuine desire in a world full of polite lies and social performance. These honest bodily reactions provide rare moments of truth between people who otherwise must constantly manage their presentations to each other.
The permission to be verbally and physically rough during sex offers another form of liberation from civilized constraints. Within the safety of mutual consent, lovers can express aspects of themselves normally repressed by social demands for kindness and politeness. This temporary permission to be "bad" paradoxically becomes an expression of deep trust and acceptance, as partners demonstrate they can see each other's shadow sides without losing fundamental respect and love.
The Civilization Paradox: Why Sexual Repression Enables Human Progress
Sexual liberation movements have consistently portrayed repression as an arbitrary imposition by religious and social authorities, but this view ignores the functional relationship between sexual constraint and civilized achievement. Sex genuinely threatens the disciplined focus required for sustained intellectual, creative, and social accomplishment. Its power to overwhelm rational priorities makes some degree of repression necessary for individual and collective flourishing.
Internet pornography provides the clearest contemporary example of sexuality's destructive potential when unleashed without restraint. Millions of hours that might otherwise be devoted to productive endeavors disappear into compulsive consumption of sexual imagery. The immediate availability of infinite sexual stimulation exploits psychological vulnerabilities that evolved in environments with much more limited temptation, effectively hijacking attention and motivation systems essential for meaningful accomplishment.
Secular societies pride themselves on sexual freedom, but this liberty often proves paradoxically imprisoning. The assumption that mature adults can easily handle unlimited sexual stimulation contradicts overwhelming evidence of addiction, compulsion, and life disruption. Only religious traditions still take seriously sexuality's power to derail other essential human projects, understanding that some desires must be constrained for the sake of spiritual, intellectual, and moral development.
The capacity for sexual restraint historically enabled the channeling of erotic energy into artistic, intellectual, and spiritual achievements. Sublimation transforms raw sexual drive into more complex and socially valuable forms of creative expression. Without some mechanism for redirecting sexual energy, individuals struggle to sustain the focused attention required for mastery in any demanding field.
Modern therapeutic culture pathologizes sexual frustration and infrequency, assuming that healthy individuals should enjoy regular, satisfying sexual activity. This medicalization ignores the possibility that sexual difficulty might be natural and that accepting certain limitations could prove more psychologically healthy than demanding constant satisfaction. A mature approach to sexuality requires acknowledging that desire often conflicts with other valuable pursuits, making strategic sacrifice and compromise essential life skills.
The Marriage Delusion: Debunking the Bourgeois Ideal of Total Fulfillment
The modern institution of marriage represents an historically unprecedented attempt to satisfy all human needs for love, sex, and family through a single relationship. This bourgeois ideal emerged relatively recently and differs dramatically from earlier arrangements that separated romantic love, sexual pleasure, and child-rearing into distinct spheres. The contemporary expectation that one person should provide complete emotional and sexual fulfillment creates impossible pressures that inevitably lead to disappointment and conflict.
Long-term relationships face inherent obstacles to sustained sexual passion that no amount of technique or therapy can fully overcome. The shift from courtship to domestic partnership requires completely different psychological skills—administrative competence, conflict resolution, and practical cooperation rather than romantic excitement and erotic playfulness. These incompatible demands make it nearly impossible to maintain sexual intensity alongside the mundane requirements of shared life.
Freud's insight about the incest taboo reveals a deeper psychological barrier to married sexuality. As couples develop parental identities through child-rearing, they unconsciously begin to resemble the family figures with whom sex was originally forbidden. The deeper their love becomes, the more it resembles the non-sexual intimacy of childhood, making erotic desire feel increasingly inappropriate and difficult to sustain.
Sexual infrequency in marriage often stems not from lack of attraction but from accumulated resentment over seemingly minor issues. Partners fire invisible arrows of disappointment throughout daily life—failing to notice haircuts, leaving messes, showing insufficient interest in each other's concerns. These small wounds create emotional distance that manifests as sexual withdrawal, even when neither person consciously recognizes their anger.
The expectation that spouses should remain sexually excited by each other after years of familiarity contradicts fundamental psychological patterns of habituation and novelty-seeking. Rather than pathologizing sexual decline as dysfunction requiring treatment, couples might benefit from accepting it as natural and focusing on other forms of intimacy and mutual support. This acceptance could reduce the shame and conflict that often make sexual relationships worse than they need to be.
The Integration Challenge: Reconciling Sexual Desire with Moral Living
Sexual desire cannot be easily integrated with moral living because it fundamentally operates according to different principles than ethical behavior. Sex often involves objectification, inequality, transgression, and selfish pleasure-seeking that would be problematic in other contexts. Rather than denying this tension, mature individuals must find ways to accommodate sexual impulses while maintaining commitment to broader ethical principles.
The phenomenon of impotence illustrates how moral sensitivity can actually interfere with sexual function. Men who become overly concerned with their partners' consent and pleasure may find themselves unable to maintain the focused selfishness that effective sexual performance sometimes requires. This dysfunction represents not pathology but the collision between civilized empathy and animal instinct—a sign of moral development rather than personal failure.
Adultery presents one of the clearest examples of the conflict between sexual desire and ethical commitment. The intense pleasure of new romantic and sexual connection directly threatens the stability of family life and existing relationships. Neither complete suppression of these desires nor unlimited indulgence offers a satisfactory solution, requiring instead ongoing negotiation between competing values and needs.
The attempt to create "enlightened" pornography that combines sexual excitement with moral values represents one approach to integration. Rather than accepting the typical opposition between sexuality and virtue, such efforts seek to channel erotic energy toward appreciation of intelligence, kindness, and other admirable qualities. This suggests possibilities for forms of sexual expression that enhance rather than undermine other aspects of human flourishing.
Censorship of sexual material need not represent prudish repression but could instead reflect mature recognition of sexuality's power to disrupt other valuable pursuits. Just as societies regulate alcohol and drugs while acknowledging their legitimate pleasures, sexual imagery might require careful management to prevent it from overwhelming rational decision-making and long-term planning. Such regulation serves not moralistic condemnation but practical wisdom about human psychological limitations.
Summary
Sexual desire emerges from this analysis not as a problem to be solved but as an essential aspect of human nature that requires ongoing accommodation and management. The attempt to achieve perfect sexual fulfillment through liberation, technique, or ideal relationships consistently fails because it misunderstands sex as fundamentally disruptive to other important human projects. Accepting this disruption as natural rather than pathological allows for more realistic expectations and healthier responses to sexual frustration and complexity.
The most profound insight concerns sex's role as both a source of transcendent connection and inevitable disappointment. While sexual intimacy offers precious opportunities to overcome isolation and experience mutual recognition, it also creates conflicts with family stability, professional focus, and moral consistency that cannot be perfectly resolved. Mature individuals learn to appreciate sex's gifts while accepting its costs, finding meaning in the ongoing negotiation between desire and other values rather than seeking final solutions to eternal tensions.
Download PDF & EPUB
To save this Black List summary for later, download the free PDF and EPUB. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.